So update on this, I finally got it to work but the reason why it wasn't working is weird.
I tried what @budadeth suggested, changing my resolution to 1920x1080 but it still was not working. I then tried for the combinations of and "UI Scaling" and "High DPI Fonts" when I misclicked "Small HUD Menu," turning it off. Now my Interface settings looks like this at 1920x1027 resolution.
EDIT: It stopped working when I added mods, didn't get fixed when the mods were removed.