100% Agreed.
I completely do not follow OP's logic on why this needs to be a 'challenge' that we need to overcome. Why exactly does it need to be some kind of puzzle we need to solve?
- Let's say all your nerfs are implemented, and you 'figure out the puzzle.' Now you know how to catch alphas without any of the listed suggestions - are you gonna ask for a nerf again?
Even with all the current strats available, plenty of my friends spend more timer balls than the Alpha was worth on the GTL to catch it.
To me it makes 0 sense why any user would literally be asking for devs to nerf our ability to catch mons during limited time events.
If a challenge is what you want, go make it a challenge for yourself. Limit yourself to not using any of the suggestions you listed - don't drag everybody else down with you.
FYI - I rarely spend more than 15minutes catching any alpha, and even the current state I consider too long given:
1) the limited time you have to catch them.
2) not everybody is monitoring Alpha swarm appearances like a hawk = we don't have 75 minutes to catch.
I found out about Ditto this morning 45 minutes into the swarm so I only had 30 minutes to get there and try and catch it, and I was in a 3k+ queue.
Most of us don't start right when an Alpha spawns, and there are long queue times - you still want to make this process take longer?
This is quite honestly an asinine take to me.
If you want a challenge, do it yourself.