RIP SUGGESTION BOX ZOMG KJSFNKJARFWRJF NO ORGANIZATION!!!1!!!!
Jk but yeah kind of serious. Please trash the ToC as it's an insult to the organization this section used to have.
Anywho, I am pretty up and down about this. I understand the benefits and it may encourage competitive play a bit but at the end of the day this is a MMO and having to grow, restore, buy, trade for berries makes sense... and probably having to do that for other held items occasionally does too. PvP is the endgame, and I think it should cost a bit for people to play it.
Not suggesting anything ridiculous obviously.
So yeah, I guess I am against it. Although I don't think it's ridiculous at the moment since most items are finite use and do not break/need replacing. It does follow the current theme in game as far as PvP items are concerned, but I just think the entire thing will need to change at some point, although it won't be "fun" for competitive players, etc.