Hey, I'm a mid Tier pvp player and have been playing for 2 years now, so take it easy on me if I say something crazy. I made this account today just so I could share my POV on this topic.
I usually play Balanced or hyper offense with mon that just happen to be strong against Gallade and so with those play styles I dont have a hard time beating gallade AND winning the game. Now I can definitely see how someone who plays stall MOST of the time is having a terrible time against it. I don't think sharpness is broken but the power it has in combination with the variety of sets, I think can be. I do not think sharpness should be banned or nerfed. I think if anything the move set should be nerfed. From my experience its just stall teams that lose Because of gallade every other play style may take a loss from gallade but that's not the reason they lost if they lost.
This is might be a crazy take but I look at gallade in a similar way that I look at togekiss. Scarf kiss is great against hyper offense and you hardly need skill to use it. Gallade is great against stall teams and you hardly need skill to use it against stall unless its scarfed and you need to predict correctly. Making it MORE predictable than it already is by nerfing move set would help the stall players play stall and I think that's the right way to go about it.
I also want to say that if we have some new HA for WALLS that can handle gallade that would be better than banning or nerfing.
The current meta may have caused volatility in win rates for the high ranking players but from a new player/casual standpoint It makes it a lot of fun.
