[Sig] Signature Rating Thread

[Xand]

You can discuss signatures and their ratings in this thread, create them and post to show your friends for their opinions!

 

The signatures may be rated 1-10, on lowest-highest scale, and can include constructive criticism on how to improve said signature. 

 

Remember to keep it civil and abide by the Code of Conduct at all times.

 

Edited June 1, 2016 by Xand
Added a little spliff splaff to make it slightly more personable. (Best you're going to get)

[NaitDawg]

Too many premade brushes 4/10 

[Bimps1002]

Too many premade brushes 4/10 

too much wings

[hydroimpact]

Would somebody mind rating the one I made please? :)

[lillyfly]

things Deejaye makes > all

[PeyPey]

Would somebody mind rating the one I made please? :)

too much going on i rate 6 overall kind of good

[PeyPey]

hows this?

[Dannnno]

hows this?

 

I like it, but the text is a little hard to read and the salamence (which I'm assuming is supposed to be the focal point) doesn't attract as much attention. 6-7/10

[remy1jd]

RATE MINE XD

[Dannnno]

 

I'm in general not a fan of random gif signatures, so like 4/10.  It isn't particularly interesting or cool, its just some Korean model (I think)

[remy1jd]

I'm in general not a fan of random gif signatures, so like 4/10.  It isn't particularly interesting or cool, its just some Korean model (I think)

XD so funny

[Bimps1002]

You remind me of Hitmanx.

And let me friendly remind you that he's banned for the same thing as you are doing now

rule 1: never take me seriously

[TheOriginal]

rule 1: never take me seriously

your sig is glorious

what about mine? thanks Jwong

[remy1jd]

how about these?

hydroimpact ftw

[Sashimi]

Rate mine.

[remy1jd]

Rate mine.

that is like a 7.5/10 

dont scare children like that Rilleh

[TheOriginal]

how about these?

hydroimpact ftw

too much going on in all of them

6/10 for all

Rate mine.

I really like yours, 9/10 though because dont like the smiley face on hypno

[GymLeaderGreen]

Doesnt this thread already exist?

[JWingWangWong]

Bashes fun/10

That's what you wanted, right?

[Dannnno]

Doesnt this thread already exist?

 

They trashed that one

[remy1jd]

someone else rate mine lol

[Sashimi]

how about these?

hydroimpact ftw

Just cuz it hurts my eyes 7.1/10

EDIT: I am joking. 

rate this pls

[TheOriginal]

Just cuz it hurts my eyes 7.1/10

 

rate this pls

pokemon should be more visible, i dont know what that is bottom right, 7/10

[Dannnno]

your sig is glorious

what about mine? thanks Jwong

 

looks decent, not a huge fan of the background and layout though. 7/10

 

how about these?

hydroimpact ftw

 

Too much going on, not rendered that well, hard to see. all 4-5/10

 

Rate mine.

 

spooky, but well done. 7-8/10

 

Just cuz it hurts my eyes 7.1/10

EDIT: I am joking. 

rate this pls

 

Hard to see and understand so about 5/10, but donatello so 10/10

[Sashimi]

I found it. First sig I ever used...then so on...

 

Credit:Deejaye