[Sig] Signature Rating Thread

[TheGloriousWalrus]

How's this signature I made?~

I like it, the text goes well with the background. And the colors go well with shuckle. I don't really think the speech balloon fits in it though

[Imbalance]

^ I like walrein 8/10

 

how is mine

 

I made it with paint lol

[TheGloriousWalrus]

Updated mine...HOW IS IT?!

[Imbalance]

[Hol]

How's this signature I made?~

 

I like it a lot. I love your sigs <3

[jayfeatskydd]

How's this signature I made?~

Do not fuckle with the Shuckle.

[Hol]

I'm trying out stuff. How does this look?

 

[Psycatrix]

Hol, sorry, 3/10.

I'll try to explain you why I don't like it... :/

First, I need to say that animate your sig is not a necessity. It remove a bit of quality on it, and I think you have to do it only if you're sig has a very high quality.

The animation of you text is too fast i think, and I don't like a lot the border... Try to put the charmander above your text.

Can you please rate mine, thanks

[hydroimpact]

I'm trying out stuff. How does this look?

 

 

Got Charmander, good enough for me <3 7.5/10

[PeaceG]

Hol, sorry, 3/10.

I'll try to explain you why I don't like it... :/

First, I need to say that animate your sig is not a necessity. It remove a bit of quality on it, and I think you have to do it only if you're sig has a very high quality.

The animation of you text is too fast i think, and I don't like a lot the border... Try to put the charmander above your text.

Can you please rate mine, thanks

The smudge is kinda random(Goes in all directions)
And those lines coming from the swords are just odd, you should erase em

Overall it looks kinda dull, try adding gradient masks and stuffs

[Volums]

Nice concept but the colors don't mix well.

7/10

[Hol]

How about this one?

 

[eggroll]

 

 

 

 

 

didn't know this thread existed, made these for my team  :ph34r:

[DoubleJ]

 

 

 

 

 

didn't know this thread existed, made these for my team  :ph34r:

 

This is that moment where I finally understand those patients who are sitting in the ER bed talking on their phones, eating McDonalds, and telling me they have 10/10 pain.

 

I'm in bed, didn't react one bit, but these sigs just too good. 10/10 no doubt.

[Hol]

 

 

 

 

 

didn't know this thread existed, made these for my team  :ph34r:

 

10/10. They all look amazing.

[TheGloriousWalrus]

 

 

 

 

 

didn't know this thread existed, made these for my team  :ph34r:

 

10/10. They all look amazing.

[Vaeldras]

 

 

10/10 Glorious,a fine piece of art.

[jayfeatskydd]

 

 

 

 

 

didn't know this thread existed, made these for my team  :ph34r:

Pretty dope

[Jate]

FIrst sig ever, just got into photoshop. Any constructive criticism?

Also didnt really wanna post it after those beautiful ones up there

 

Edit: Heres my 2nd one

I like it a lil better

 

Edit2: Incoming more attempts xD

 

[razuhiko]

How about this one?

 

 woa! great sig :D 9/10

[Noir]

FIrst sig ever, just got into photoshop. Any constructive criticism?

Also didnt really wanna post it after those beautiful ones up there

 

Edit: Heres my 2nd one

I like it a lil better

 

Edit2: Incoming more attempts xD

 

 

 

Most of your stuff is overly-sharpened, and this is only emphasised by the animation which requires saving in .gif format which induces heaps of quality loss by itself. For those just starting out, I would advise you to stay away from animated tags. I know they're a huge thing on this forum but a lot of them tend to come out looking pretty tacky especially due to the .gif quality loss. Stick to static tags for now and work on improving your sense of flow, lighting and depth. Rather than just making a random background and wacking on a render and some text, try experimenting with the placement of a render relative to the background effects you are trying to achieve and have a background which complements both your render and the overall atmosphere of the tag. It's generally advisable to stay away from text when starting out because it ruins flow unless you do it right but it's up to you (I'm a bit of a hypocrite here since the text in p much all my tags screws up the flow). I will say though that you needn't use massive font sizes and overly garish effects on your text, rather you should go for a more subtle approach which matches the style of the tag. These are great for your first shots at tag making and they're a lot better than what I first whipped up when I was getting into it, just give it time and practice and you'll improve massively. :)

 

---

 

Back from hiatus with a new tag, CnC would be wonderful!

 

 

[YumiLove]

So many good sigs /jealous
I've been trying to learn, I suck really. Tried keeping it simple. Failed at animating text and what not so gave up.

Tried to make mine look as cute as possible. *.*

[Sammier]

So many good sigs /jealous
I've been trying to learn, I suck really. Tried keeping it simple. Failed at animating text and what not so gave up.

Tried to make mine look as cute as possible. *.*

Its pretty cute.
Also about the animation, try this guide. It's pretty detailed and with Pictures :3.

https://forums.pokemmo.eu/index.php?/topic/37866-tutorial-bubblys-sig-making-helpdesk-how-to-make-shining-text/

[YumiLove]

Its pretty cute.
Also about the animation, try this guide. It's pretty detailed and with Pictures :3.

https://forums.pokemmo.eu/index.php?/topic/37866-tutorial-bubblys-sig-making-helpdesk-how-to-make-shining-text/

Yeah, it's a good tutorial except I use Photoshop elements 12 and it doesn't have that animation frame tab at the bottom or an option for it in the windows thingy, so I'm pretty stumped >.<

I guess I'll try and get a version of Photoshop CC. e.e''

[Electruz]

Stop lying, Yumi. You make amazing signatures! I'd like some more in the future. ;) (rate mine, pls, to embarrass her and make her feel amazing unless it's like 1/10 qq)